Inside PR

How can we get more women in PR's top jobs?

Date: 24 February 2011 10:54
Join our community

According to the latest CIPR's Annual State of the PR Profession Survey, the PR jobs market is dominated by women (65 per cent are female), yet men are more likely to hold a senior management or director position and are almost twice as likely to be earning a salary in excess of £50,000.

Of course there should be more women at board level in PR, but as with other professions, it is hard balancing having a family with a demanding job, and it‘s usually women who take on the brunt of childcare.

Yet some women with families do succeed. Jane Wilson, CEO at the CIPR says it is not easy to pinpoint exactly what women who hold down top jobs have in common. But she can draw on her own experience: “From a personal perspective, I suppose I am a woman in a senior role in public relations and I’ve been at board level or similar positions since my late twenties. As I look at my career, I cannot honestly say that I’ve found it harder to succeed because of my gender. But I’ve had to make choices about my priorities at different stages in my life.

“When I was younger I was free to work and play hard with few other time commitments. Now that I have other personal responsibilities, including young children, I manage my life in a different way. I’m lucky though. I have always had a great network of friends and family who supported my career and helped me out.

Wilson concludes that ultimately, women with families require a great support system: “The more responsibilities you have in your life – and the majority of women as child bearers do tend to have more – the better the support network you need. Whether that’s a supportive husband, a great nanny or an inspiring boss who pays for your professional development.  If you can focus on the job in hand, you’re more likely to at least start on an even footing to your male counterparts.”

Another way to encourage women with families is to allow them to work flexibly. Lisa Doherty, marketing manager at PR agency Nelson Bostock Group, says this is vital and PR firms must have flexible working practices if they want to hold on to talented staff. However, she believes the PR industry is slow to adopt such practices, probably because it’s service based and therefore wants to be constantly available to clients, staff and fellow senior colleagues. She advises learning from clients: “Most of us, at some point, have worked with clients that have a flexible working policy, with some of them even having incentive schemes to get women back to work following maternity leave. It’s surprising then that the PR industry hasn’t followed suit quite as quickly, especially in such a female-dominated industry, and when you consider how much we invest in employees, not to mention the knowledge and expertise that is being lost.”

Doherty says that flexible working is easy to implement and improves productivity. “We currently have members of staff working flexibly – myself included – and over a year later it’s still working well for me. People now recognise when I’m in the office and structure meetings/deadlines accordingly. I have not yet encountered any negative reactions or any barriers when discussing career advancement.

“Flexible working increases productivity. When you’re only in the office a set amount of time, you tend to be more focused and need to make sure you are on top of your game, as well as your workload. So, with a bit more open-minded flexibility from PR employers there should be no reason why women can’t make it to the top in PR.”

Share this article


Stay in touch with PRmoment.com

Comments

Let's be honest, despite all these lovely idyllic comments about working flexibly - it's still very hard to combine motherhood and being a director - as clients need you 24/7 and your male counterparts don't appreciate it much either. I've seen few women do it so far - most go freelance and wfh - which can be a great alternative.

Name: sue grant
onechocolatecomms.co.uk
Date: 25 Feb 2011 09:23 AM

No need to be defeatist! Everything is manageable. In order for anyone to get to the top (either male or female) they have to be a good manager. Juggling the whole family/career thing is simply another management challenge and need not phase anyone. The answer is a superb support system, a sense of humour and a sense of balance. It is not actually that difficult.

Name: Angela Casey
www.cmporternovelli.co.uk
Date: 25 Feb 2011 10:13 AM

I wrote a post on PR being a woman's world last week: http://www.prconversations.com/index.php/2011/02/pr-its-a-womans-world/ - with some good discussion from commentators on the post. A couple of other thoughts - first as yesterday's publication of the Davies report shows, the male domination in senior positions is not restricted to PR. It also reveals that there may be functional issues to be addressed and not simply this being an individual woman's problem. Angela seems to imply that anyone who cannot manage their work-life balance is incompetent. Looking at the CIPR data from the State of the Profession report (and bearing in mind this was a self-selected sample of its membership) - and wider evidence from the educational success of girls, the issue is more one of why bright, young women entering the workforce are not yet making it in large numbers to the board room. Do we need to raise aspirations or are there cultural (Sky Sports anyone?) and other barriers in the way? I'd be particularly interested in views from the large PR consultancies where there definitely seems to be a practice of recruiting in former BBC and national newspaper journalists to senior roles. Why aren't they developing the largely female talent they recruit to fill the top posts?

Name: Heather Yaxley
www.greenbanana.wordpress.com
Date: 25 Feb 2011 10:42 AM

As the article suggests, you need a good support network and flexible working arrangements with the employer. Working mothers are not afraid to put the extra hours in to get the job done; it may not be within the regular 9-5 hours.

Name: Chen-Lee Tsui
www.BusinessWire.co.uk
Date: 25 Feb 2011 11:21 AM

All professions - not just PR - face the issue of a lack of diversity at the top. I was fortunate enough to be involved in Davies report process and while the formal sessions were closed, one of the themes which came out in informal discussion with other participants afterwards was that there is no one single reason for the imbalance in UK boardrooms and that's what makes finding a solution difficult. That was my biggest challenge in providing a comment for this article. I'm certainly not qualified to speak on behalf of all professional women, never mind all working mothers, so really could only comment on some of my own experiences. The issue of women being under represented at the top of organisations isn't limited to those who choose to have children. It's hard work getting to the top of a profession, whether you are a man or a woman, and many men also have to make personal sacrifices to pursue career goals. But the figures from business would suggest that there are cultural hurdles that need addressed. Either women generally are less likely to 'want' to be in the Boardroom or something internally or externally is stopping them getting there. And what responsibilities do those of us who have supposedly 'made it' have to young women coming through the ranks today? Is it enough just to strive to be professional and demonstrate that our capabilities are not gender dependent or must today's senior women do more to give the next generation a helping hand? I hope that in my lifetime, through education and a cultural shift, this imbalance is relegated to history and I'm happy to take any personal responsibility to help make that happen.

Name: Jane Wilson
www.cipr.co.uk
Date: 28 Feb 2011 01:30 PM

Couldn't agree more on the importance of flexibility. My employer eventually allowed me to work flexible hours whilst staying full-time in a senior management role and it has been a godsend. I still bust a gut to do a great job, and I'm available on the phone and email throughout the week. I often work in the evenings when the kids have gone to bed and occasionally have moments when I am on the phone to a Govt minister with kids in the background! But as long as I get results, put in the hours at other times, and do a good job that's what matters. I'm much happier and productive when the work-kids balance is right, and have never missed a sports day or school play. When I'm at work I am 100% committed/focussed and can get though a lot more work than some of my colleagues even though I occasionally leave earlier. It's always a juggle being a working mum, even in this modern world, but if employers support you it can work for both sides. And it helps if your mother-in-law does the ironing...

Name: Sara Reed
www.mod.uk
Date: 28 Feb 2011 02:47 PM

This whole area is a crucial one for recruiting and -more to the point- retaining, the very best talent for our industry. That's why it's one of the key topics of the PRCA Access Commission, chaired by Insight PA's John Lehal, and which met for the first time last night. It's composed of some of the most senior people within our industry, from consultancies, in house teams and academia alike (including a former CIPR Professional Practices Committee Chairman as it happens). It will report back later in the year with a series of practical recommendations, including on working mums. There's been too much talk and too little action on access in recent years. We intend to put this right. So watch this space!

Name: Francis Ingham
www.prca.org.uk
Date: 08 Mar 2011 04:20 PM

Post a Comment
Name Comments
Website
Email
Tick to receive comment notifications for this article  

Enter the words above: